Israel’s Disappointing Political
Process
By Sherwin Pomerantz
There are times, like today, when I really miss and envy the political
process in my birth country, the United States of America.
Yesterday Israel swore in its 33rd government since the country’s
creation in 1948. The new cabinet seems
to me to be a clear reflection of what the voters here stated loud and clear on
Election Day in January, to wit:
·
There is no better person in the country today than Benjamin Netanyahu to
be the Prime Minister.
·
But there is disappointment in certain aspects of how he runs the country
so let’s clip his wings a bit and not give him as strong a mandate as in the
previous election.
·
It’s time for new blood in the Knesset, so let’s elect 43 of the 120
delegates who have never served before and have no allegiance to political
kingmakers and see how they make out.
·
We are concerned about how best to deal with the fact that Israel has the
highest percentage of any OECD country of people not in the work force who are
eligible to be in the work force and we need to address that in order to remain
economically stable.
·
Perhaps it is time for the government coalition not to include the
religious parties and to at least begin to address the issue of separation of
church and state.
This, of course, is my personal interpretation although the election of two
brand new parties to the 2nd (Yesh Atid) and 3rd (Bayit
HaYehudi) place positions as vote-getters along with the reduction in seats of
the first place Likud-Beytenu faction would seem to support my position.
After weeks of coalition building today’s papers detail the members of a
cabinet thankfully reduced in size from the last government (which saves those
of us who are taxpayers millions of dollars).
One would think that the press and electorate would wish them well.
Ah, but this is Israel and the tradition here is exactly opposite from that
of the US. In the US there is a
tradition, after an election, of people rallying together for the good and
welfare of the community in order to move the public sector forward. Sadly, in
Israel, the approach is exactly the opposite where the losers work hard to
prove that those who voted the elected officials into office made a mistake.
Last Friday’s papers in the religious community, for example, blared out
the headline “An Evil Government” once it was announced that the coalition had
been formed and the religious parties would be in the opposition.
This morning’s Ha’aretz, in reviewing the new ministers, referred nastily to
Rabbi Shai Peron, a member of the Yesh Atid party and the new Minister of
Education as “one who used to run a yeshiva and will now be in charge of the
entire educational system,” as if it should be clear to all of us that he will
fail. This, of course, is the same paper
that four years ago praised the appointment of Yuval Steinitz as Minister of
Finance even though he had no experience whatsoever in that discipline.
Finally, pretty much every news outlet is already predicting the fact that
the new government will be unmanageable and will have a limited life.
How sad. How sad that this country
which has become the envy of the world (even of our enemies) when it comes to
technological achievement cannot mature in the political sphere to the point
where we applaud, support and encourage the success of a new government,
regardless of our private disappointments.
Benjamin Franklin once said “Any fool can criticize, condemn and complain –
and most fools do.” That’s a lesson that
our electorate needs to internalize for the ultimate good and welfare of the
State of Israel, the fulfillment of God’s promise to those he brought out of
Egypt so many years ago.
No comments:
Post a Comment